The Odd Couple (Petaluma)

There’s a certain segment of the “thea-tuh” community that turns its collective nose up at the mere mention of a mainstream, commercially-successful playwright. One of my most vivid college memories is of a member of the Theatre Arts faculty nearly having a stroke at the mention of the possibility of scheduling a Neil Simon play in their season. These artists often measure success by how badly attended their productions are, revelling in the confirmation of how unique and right they are about what is art and how wrong everybody else is.

Director Jennifer King graciously admits to prescribing to some of these thoughts, particularly about Neil Simon, till an actor who she greatly respects prodded her into taking a look at Simon’s The Odd Couple. The next thing she knew she was directing a production of it, now running at Petaluma’s Cinnabar Theater.


Tim Setzer, Zachary Stockton, Chad Yarish, Aaron Wilton, Nathan Cummings, Tim Kniffin

The Odd Couple may be the most post popular American play ever written. From its premiere on Broadway over fifty years ago to the classic Jack Lemmon – Walter Matthau film to its current third incarnation as a prime-time television sitcom, The Odd Couple, with slight modifications (including a Saturday morning cartoon with an anthropomorphized cat and dog as the leads,) endures. Why? Because it’s funny.

The premise is simple – mismatched roommates. There, I summed up the plot in two words. There’s a whole lot more than that, of course, but it’s with that now-classic premise to which most people can relate.  Who hasn’t roomed with a Felix and/or Oscar at some point in their life? Who hasn’t been driven up a wall by a compadre’s peccadilloes? Who hasn’t reached out to help a friend in one moment and then turn around and want to kill him in the next?


Aaron Wilton, Nathan Cummings

Friendship is at the heart of The Odd Couple, male friendship in particular (though Simon adapted the play himself in 1985 as The Female Odd Couple.) and King has cast the show with a group of guys who you can actually believe are friends. Nathan Cummings brings a gruff charm to Oscar and Aaron Wilton nails both the prissiness and heart of Felix. Both manage to avoid comparisons to Matthau/Lemmon/Klugman/Randall, with Wilton’s Felix wound a bit tighter than usual.  Wilton may come off as a tad young to be playing the middle-aged Felix, but his character choices get you past that. They’re both fun to watch.

A lot of the humor in the play comes from Felix and Oscar’s poker-playing buddies, and King has cast these supporting roles as well as her leads. Tim Kniffin is very dry as accountant Roy. Tim Setzer, usually seem locally in musicals, is amusing as henpecked Vinnie. Zachary Stockton as the cigar-chewing, wise-cracking Speed is a man after my own heart with his laser-like focus on the game. Chad Yarish’s Murray the cop is the heart and soul of the group, managing to be funny and kind of sweet when it comes to caring about his friend Felix. How the hell this disparate group of guys became friends is never addressed, but before you go challenging their believability take a look at your own.

Laughs also come via the Pigeon sisters (nicely played by Samantha Dakin and Morgan Harrington), a couple of British expatriates who are the source of the final conflict (and resolution) between Oscar and Felix.


Aaron Wilton, Nathan Cummings, Samantha Dakin, Morgan Harrington

In a pre-show presentation, director King addressed the personal challenge of putting on a straight forward production and resisting the temptation to add any avant-garde elements.  I can’t imagine this show done with a minimalist set instead of Joseph Elwick’s nicely designed NY apartment or everyone dressed in black instead of Skipper Skeoch’s nicely understated period dress.  King met the challenge by simply sticking to the script and trusting her actors.

While there are individual lines that date the show ($280 a month for an eight room, New York City apartment?!) the show itself does not come off that way. Rooted in real relationships, it’s a funny look at the American male psyche, still gloriously flawed after fifty years.

Cinnabar Theater’s The Odd Couple is an extremely enjoyable production of an American comedy classic.

The Odd Couple 

Presented by Cinnabar Arts 

through April 23 

Friday/Saturday @ 8pm / Sunday @ 2pm

Cinnabar Theater
3333 Petaluma Blvd N
Petaluma, CA 94952

(707) 763-8920


Photos by Eric Chazankin

About the Author

Harry DukeHarry Duke is an actor, director, teacher, and theatre critic whose reviews can be seen online at the For All Events website and in print in the Sonoma County Gazette. He can also be heard weekly on KSRO's "The Drive with Steve Jaxon" and KRCB's "Second Row Center". He holds a B.A. in Theatre Arts from Sonoma State University where he graduated magna cum laude. He is an active member of the San Francisco Bay Area theatre community and has appeared in an average of three shows a year for the past several years. He has been seen on stage in roles as varied as Pozzo in Waiting for Godot to Mushnik in Little Shop of Horrors. He is also the Senior Arts and Entertainment Editor for The Worst Show on the Web, a popular podcast and entertainment site where his musings on the current state of film, television and pop culture can be found.View all posts by Harry Duke →